Pirelli General Cable Works Ltd v Oscar Faber & Partners
The case of Pirelli General Cable Works Ltd v Oscar Faber & Partners [1983] has been used as precedent for the limitation period applicable to claims of negligent design.
Damage to a factory arose out of the use of a material in constructing a factory chimney that was unsuitable for the purpose. The chimney had been built in 1969 but the faulty condition of the chimney could not have been discovered with reasonable diligence until 1972 and was not in fact discovered until 1977. A writ was issued in 1978. The question was whether the six year period ran from the date the faulty chimney was built or from the date when the fault could have been or was discovered. |
https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200506/ldjudgmt/jd060301/haward-2.htm |
The House of Lords held that the owner of a building had a legitimate cause of action against the consulting engineer for a negligent design at the point at which physical damage to the building first occurred.
The subsequent case of Abbott v Will Gannon & Smith Ltd [2005] challenged the Pirelli law at the Court of Appeal on the basis that the case of Murphy v Brentwood DC [1991] decided that the cause of action accrued, not when physical damage first occurred but when the building owner suffered economic loss.
The Court held that the Murphy decision had not expressly or impliedly overruled the Pirelli decision. It held that if the claimant’s cause of action accrued at the time they suffered economic loss, then the loss only occurred when it became apparent in some way which would affect the building’s value. Therefore, they rejected the argument that economic loss was suffered when negligent works were completed.
[edit] Find out more
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Featured articles and news
HBPT and BEAMS Jubilees. Book review.
Does the first Labour budget deliver for the built environment?
What does the UK Budget mean for electrical contractors?
Mixed response as business pays, are there silver linings?
A brownfield housing boost for Liverpool
A 56 million investment from Homes England now approved.
Fostering a future-ready workforce through collaboration
Collaborative Futures: Competence, Capability and Capacity, published and available for download.
Considerate Constructors Scheme acquires Building A Safer Future
Acquisition defines a new era for safety in construction.
AT Awards evening 2024; the winners and finalists
Recognising professionals with outstanding achievements.
Reactions to the Autumn Budget announcement
And key elements of the quoted budget to rebuild Britain.
Chancellor of the Exchequer delivers Budget
Repairing, fixing, rebuilding, protecting and strengthening.
Expectation management in building design
Interest, management, occupant satisfaction and the performance gap.
Connecting conservation research and practice with IHBC
State of the art heritage research & practice and guidance.
Innovative Silica Safety Toolkit
Receives funding boost in memory of construction visionary.
Gentle density and the current context of planning changes
How should designers deliver it now as it appears in NPPF.
Sustainable Futures. Redefining Retrofit for Net Zero Living
More speakers confirmed for BSRIA Briefing 2024.
Making the most of urban land: Brownfield Passports
Policy paper in brief with industry responses welcomed.
The boundaries and networks of the Magonsæte.